A Florida rancher says his three third generation Toyota Tundras have reached 227,000, 208,000 and 189,000 miles on their original twin turbo V6 engines, turbos and transmissions while towing heavy hay loads nearly every day. He calls them unbreakable, says none of them has been to a dealer for a repair or warranty issue, and other owners believe his choice of 5W30 oil, instead of the 0W20 Toyota specifies, may be part of the reason.
That’s a striking claim, because two of his trucks are 2022 and 2023 models, the years at the center of Toyota’s V35A engine recalls. Here is what he says keeps them running, what the oil debate gets right and wrong, and what any Tundra owner who tows hard can learn from his fleet.
Michael Sutherlin runs two ranches from Pierson, Florida, and shared his fleet this afternoon in the 2023 to 2027 Toyota Tundra Owners group on Facebook. His photos show a white Tundra SR5 crew cab with the ranch logo on the door, pulling a tandem axle trailer stacked with round hay bales.
“2023 Tundra SR5 4×4 w/ 208k original engine/turbos/ transmission/ transfer case and battery. Never been to dealership for a repair or warranty issue. Overloaded towing 90% of the time. Overworked 100% of the time. Abused by multiple drivers.”
He listed all three trucks and the mileage on each. “2022 SR5 with 227k, 2023 SR5 with 208k, 2025 SR5 with 189k. Flawless. A huge thank you to Toyota for building these tough trucks. Keeping both our ranches up and running.”
How Many Miles a Year These Tundras Really Run
The numbers become even more impressive when you do the math. If his 2025 SR5 arrived when the 2025 models reached dealers, it has likely averaged more than 80,000 miles a year.
That puts Michael’s fleet in rare company. When a 210,000 mile 2022 Tundra from Tampa Bay showed up for sale in 2024, The Drive reported that it had averaged more than 100,000 miles a year on its original engine.
High mileage Tundras used to be a V8 story. Our readers have shared older trucks like a Tundra sold at 281,000 miles and a 2010 owner who wants to drive his Tundra into the ground past 200,000 miles.
Why the Recall Years Make Michael’s Fleet Stand Out
Toyota’s first engine recall covered certain 2022 and 2023 Tundras because machining debris could damage the engine’s main bearings. Toyota’s recall instructions filed with NHTSA describe that campaign, and its remedy for affected trucks was engine replacement.
Michael’s post doesn’t say whether his 2022 and 2023 trucks fall under the recall, or whether any recall work was done. If they are covered and still running original engines at 227,000 and 208,000 miles, they show that not every recalled engine is destined to fail.
Advertising
Other owners haven’t been as lucky. A 2024 owner in our reporting needed two engines and a transmission in 22,000 miles, and Toyota’s recall work has turned into a $500 million task to replace nearly 100,000 engines.
The 5W30 Oil Debate Michael Started
Michael says he has run 5W30 oil for each truck’s whole life, since its break in oil change at 600 miles. That’s not what Toyota recommends, since the twin turbo V6 is specified for 0W20 full synthetic oil, according to Toyota’s dealer guidance.
Group member John believes the thicker oil is the reason Michael’s bearings are healthy. That theory is popular, but it has limits.
Toyota traced the recall to machining debris left in the engine at the factory, not to oil viscosity. Thicker oil can’t remove debris that was never supposed to be there, so 5W30 is unlikely to save an engine that has that defect.
Here is what the two numbers actually mean. The first number, 0W or 5W, describes how easily the oil flows on a cold start, while the second number, 20 or 30, describes how thick it stays at operating temperature.
Climate matters here. Pierson, Florida, rarely sees hard freezes, so the cold start disadvantage of a 5W oil matters far less there than in Montana or Michigan, while the extra thickness at temperature may help trucks that tow heavy loads in Florida heat.
The tradeoff is warranty risk. Michael has never needed a warranty claim, but owners who stray from the factory specification could face questions if an engine fails, which is why many owners in our story about Tundra oil change intervals keep detailed records.
What “Overloaded Towing” Means for a Tundra SR5
Michael says his trucks tow overloaded 90% of the time, and that is his word, not ours. According to TowingSpecs, the 2023 Tundra SR5 4×4 is rated at 11,200 pounds of towing with 1,885 pounds of payload, and owners should always check the sticker on their own door jamb.
Round hay bales are heavy, and a tandem trailer stacked two high, as in Michael’s photos, can add up fast. He didn’t share the weight of a typical load, and I’ll update this story if he does.
Running over the rating adds stress to brakes, the frame, the hitch and the cooling system. It also matters if something fails, because a truck that has been overloaded gives Toyota a reason to question a warranty claim.
Advertising
Not Every Owner Thinks Toyota Deserves the Credit
Brady was encouraged by Michael’s post. “Good to see I’ve got a 2017 Toyota Tacoma with 250k no issues. I run it daily up and down the highway and a 2001 Tacoma with 500k original everything drive it too as well. Wanting to get a Tundra, but was nervous about racking up miles on it, albeit I don’t tow a ton.”
Emile pushed back. “I heard similar stories all of my life and more from Fords and Chevys. 300K and more and going strong. It’s not just Toyotas. But guys that drive Toyotas desire the acknowledgement.”
Brady’s nervousness is common. A former owner who sold his 2010 Tundra at 245,000 miles told us he’s terrified of the Tundra V6, and Michael’s fleet is exactly the kind of evidence those owners have been waiting for.
How to Help a Hard Working Tundra Reach 200,000 Miles
Michael’s trucks don’t prove that any single habit guarantees a long life. But his experience, and what other high mileage owners report, points to habits worth following:
Check your recall status first. Enter your VIN on Toyota’s owner site or NHTSA’s recall lookup, because no oil choice can fix machining debris.
Change oil early when you tow. Towing counts as severe service, and many owners shorten the interval to around 5,000 miles instead of waiting for 10,000.
Keep every receipt. Detailed oil change records protect you if you ever need a warranty claim, whatever oil you run.
Don’t skip the driveline fluids. Trucks that tow daily work their transmission, transfer case and differentials hard, so follow the owner’s manual schedule for those fluids.
Stay within your ratings when you can. Weigh a typical load at a truck stop scale and compare it with your door sticker.
Listen for early warning signs. A new knock, a rattle on startup or a sudden drop in power is worth a dealer visit right away, as owners in our story about the 2024 Tundra that failed at 43,000 miles learned.
For now, Michael’s three SR5s are doing exactly what ranch trucks are supposed to do. They are working every day, piling on miles, and keeping two Florida ranches running.
Now I want to hear from you. Would you run 5W30 in your Tundra’s twin turbo V6, or stick with Toyota’s 0W20? What’s the highest mileage you’ve seen on a third generation Tundra?
Tell us in the comments below. Return tomorrow, or check our Torque News Toyota page for more Tundra owner stories.
About The Author
Armen Hareyan is the founder and Editor in Chief of Torque News, where he has covered the automotive industry for over 15 years. Now based in the Charlotte region (Indian Land, SC, he founded Torque News in 2010, which since then has been publishing expert news and analysis about the automotive industry. Armen holds three Masters Degrees, including an MBA, and has become one of the known voices in the industry, specializing in the landscape of electric vehicles and real-world stories of actual car owners. Armen focuses on providing readers with transparent, data-backed analysis bridging the gap of complex engineering and car buyer practicality. Armen regularly attends automotive drive events organized by major car brands throughout the United States, national and local car reveals and personally test-drives new vehicles every week. Armen has also been published as an automotive expert in industry magazines, discussing how will autonomous vehicles reshape the supply chain, and emerging technologies in vehicle maintenance.
Read more of Armen’s work on his author profile page.
You can also follow Armen here:
Images by Michael Sutherlin and Torque News enhancements.
Follow us today…
